Every pizza order in Pakistan eventually comes down to this. Someone wants pepperoni, someone wants chicken tikka, and the group has twenty seconds to decide before the person on the phone gets impatient.

They are not close to each other. Picking between them is really picking between two completely different ideas of what a pizza should taste like.

Quick answer: Pepperoni pizza is simple and salty — cured, spiced sausage slices over tomato sauce and mozzarella, with the fat crisping the edges as it bakes. Chicken tikka pizza is the desi version: marinated tikka chicken, onion, capsicum and often a spiced or garlic base, so it is heavier, hotter and more layered. Pepperoni suits anyone who wants classic pizza. Chicken tikka suits anyone who finds plain pizza bland.

What pepperoni actually is in Pakistan

This question comes up constantly and deserves a straight answer, because traditional pepperoni is pork.

In Pakistan it is not. Pepperoni here is made from chicken or beef, cured and spiced with paprika, chilli and fennel to produce the same deep red colour and the same salty, slightly smoky taste. It is halal, and that is the whole reason the recipe was adapted in the first place.

The spice blend does most of the work. What people recognise as the pepperoni flavour is the paprika and fennel, not the meat it started from — which is why a well-made chicken pepperoni tastes like pepperoni and not like chicken.

If you want to know exactly which meat is used in a particular pizza, the classic flavours menu lists it.

How the two actually taste

Pepperoni is about three things: salt, fat and simplicity. There is very little on the pizza besides sauce, cheese and the sausage. As it bakes, the fat renders out and the edges of each slice curl and crisp, which is why a good pepperoni pizza has those little cups of oil sitting in the slices.

It is mild. No chilli heat to speak of, just a savoury warmth from the paprika.

Chicken tikka is the opposite — a crowded pizza. Marinated chicken, onion, capsicum, sometimes jalapeño, often on a spiced base rather than plain tomato. Each bite has several things happening in it.

It is also genuinely spicy, in the way a Pakistani palate expects. The tikka marinade carries chilli and the toppings add more.

Which one to order

Order pepperoni if you want straightforward pizza, if children are eating, or if you are serving people who do not eat spicy food. It is also the better pizza for eating cold the next morning — fewer wet toppings means it holds up.

Order chicken tikka if plain pizza bores you, or if the pizza is the whole meal rather than a snack. It is more filling, and it is the one most Pakistani groups default to for a reason.

Order both if there are four or more of you. This is the honest answer and the 50% off deals make it the sensible one — two different pizzas usually costs less than you expect, and nobody has to lose the argument.

Which travels better

Worth knowing if you are ordering delivery rather than eating in.

Pepperoni holds up better. Fewer toppings means less moisture, so the base stays firmer through the journey.

Chicken tikka has onion, capsicum and marinade on it, all of which release steam inside a closed box. By the time it arrives, the centre can be softer than it was. Still good — just not the same as eating it fresh.

If delivery times are long where you are, pepperoni is the safer order. Our guide to ordering pizza online covers the rest.

The crust changes both of them

The same flavour on a different crust is a different pizza, and people underrate this.

A thin crust lets pepperoni dominate, which is what you want with a simple topping. A deep pan base gives chicken tikka something substantial to sit on, which suits a heavy topping better.

Put it the other way round — chicken tikka on thin crust, pepperoni on deep pan — and both are slightly off balance.

For what else is worth trying, our list of the pizza flavours Pakistanis order most covers the full range.

Frequently asked questions

Is pepperoni pizza halal in Pakistan?

Yes. Pepperoni sold in Pakistan is made from chicken or beef rather than pork, cured and spiced to taste the same as the traditional version.

What is pepperoni made of?

Cured, spiced sausage — chicken or beef in Pakistan — seasoned with paprika, chilli and fennel, which give it the red colour and the salty, smoky flavour.

Which is spicier, pepperoni or chicken tikka pizza?

Chicken tikka. The marinade carries chilli and the toppings add more. Pepperoni is savoury rather than hot.

Which pizza is better for children?

Pepperoni. It is mild, simple and has fewer toppings for fussy eaters to pick off.

Which pizza is better for delivery?

Pepperoni. Chicken tikka has wetter toppings that can soften the base during the journey.